Review: Dragon Ball: That time I got reincarnated as Yamcha

It's been a long time since I reviewed anything Dragon Ball related. In fact I think the last thing I reviewed was the first episode of Dragon Ball Super a few years ago, since then the series has gone on to have a renaissance of sorts through the Video Games, Manga and the recent movie. Much of this was thanks to the creation of 'The Dragon Ball Room' by rights holder Shueisha which was formed in order to support and expand the franchise.

With this room being formed in June of 2016 almost a year after the airing of the first episode of Dragon ball Super I was really excited to see what they could come up with, but I can honestly say I had no idea they would facilitate a Manga like 'That time I got reincarnated as Yamcha'.

I originally heard about this Manga online when the first chapter was released in English by Viz for free. However I never found the time to get around to reading it other than catching some scans of the odd page here and there when people would talk about it online. It was due to discussions about this Manga on Twitter that I would come to see images posted that initially I believed were from this Manga with one well known example in the fan community being Yamcha fighting Golden Frieza.

When I saw these kind of images I would laugh out loud at how ridiculous the scenarios were and decided to look a little closer into why this Manga existed in the first place, it was then that I came across the Mangaka Dragongarow LEE. LEE is responsible for the art used within this Manga as well as the general story and is well known within the Dragon Ball community due to his Doujinshi (Fan Manga/Art), so it is easy to see how he would come to be scouted to work on a one-shot like this.

According to an interview with an Editor at Shueisha it was not LEE that came up with the concept of the story initially. However due to his previous work in which Vegeta came to Earth as a child rather than Goku, being so popular amongst other staff members it was decided that LEE could also be trusted to come up with his own ideas for the story and create something that the fans would love to see.

The thing about Yamcha is, he's just a little bit useless. When he was introduced he seemed to be a pretty cool character and really fit into the adventure setting of the original series. Yet as time progressed he was shown to be a bit lazy and neglect his training until he has no other choice. It was not long after Dragon Ball Z began that Yamcha would become a joke. This was due to his loss against the Saibamen via one of them self destructing.

At the time this technique wiping an established character out instantly really showed the level of power the enemy had, even if it was just a small minion of the main threat, but in retrospect the horrible way he died just became a little funny and has become somewhat of a meme within the community. It's no secret that Shueisha would know this and perhaps it's a reason why they chose LEE who is passionate about smaller characters like Yamcha, to take the reigns.

So what is the plot? Well as the title suggests it's about being turned into Yamcha after your own death and having to deal with the world that he resides in. In other words the overall story is a case of a what if scenario where Yamcha has full knowledge of everything that was going to happen in Dragon Ball and what he would do with that information.

I'd rather not give too much away about the story because it would ruin some of the comedy involved but I will say the comedic timing and style of LEE is not dissimilar to that of original Dragon Ball author Akira Toriyama. Perhaps that is because we are reliving certain scenes where the comedy is already in place for the most part, yet LEE puts his own little spin on it and adds that extra layer that really feels welcome in the Dragon Ball world.

The art style is another big plus for me and perhaps I'm not the best authority on the matter but I really wouldn't have been able to tell that this was not drawn by Toriyama if I did not already know it was LEE. LEE's emulation of the traditional Toriyama style is absolutely fantastic and I would argue it is much better than the majority of the work on the Dragon Ball Super Manga which is headed by Toyotaro, another member of the Dragon ball community who also began as a Doujinshi Mangaka.

That is not to say that Toyotaro is bad and he has certainly improved but it has been a gradual journey that the fans have seen with each Manga chapter. Yes, LEE likely had way more time to work with and was only working on a single volume rather than an ongoing series but the differences in their emulation of Toriyamas art is hard to ignore.

I think one of the funniest aspects of the whole Manga is that the character inhabiting Yamcha just wants to get together with Bulma initially. After he realizes he's likely stuck as Yamcha forever he thinks about how he's going to survive as arguably one of the weakest character in the franchise. Thankfully he actually gets serious about making Yamcha stronger and uses his knowledge of the Manga to push himself to the highest level he can.

What's interesting is that while he does his best with his training, he is still limited in how far he can push Yamcha. He quickly discovers that he will still be no match for enemies like Frieza or Cell and due to this the Manga actually keeps itself 'realistic' within the world that it is set in. That is not to say that the story abruptly ends because of these points but it's interesting to see that Yamcha can only be pushed so far until there is no way he can continue to keep up with characters like Goku and the power of Super Saiyan.

I think that delves a little deeper into a common problem many may find with the series, in that the power levels are just astronomical at this point and you never get to see a lot of the side characters like Yamcha or Piccolo during the latter parts of Z. This has been slightly rectified in recent years with Revival of F movie and the Tournament of Power Arc in the Anime but it is still very much the 'Saiyan show' overall.

Skipping ahead, the last chapter honestly took a turn that I did not expect and even involved the Mobile game Dokkan Battle which I'm embarrassed to admit took up too much of my time in the past. I wasn't sure how I felt about the sudden change in story and tone at first but now I have had time to sit on it, and after reading the Manga a number of times since then, I felt it was a satisfying end to the story rather than having Yamcha just 'Retire' it gave one last hurrah to the character in some form.

There are some Bonus chapters that answer questions such like, 'if he knew everything why didn't he use fusion on some tougher enemies' which has a hilarious result and even uses the characters knowledge of games like Dragon Ball Fusions to their advantage. The Manga generally ties into so many different aspects of the franchise and the whole reason the main character even got reincarnated as Yamcha is etched into characters I thought would be totally absent from this story.

It's fair to say this is a Manga by a fan for the fans, much like the Doujinshi worked on in the past by LEE. It's reasons like this that make me so proud to be a part of this global community that never ceases to amaze me.

The Manga is relatively short, so much so that you will likely finish it in under 30 minutes. I wouldn't say this is a complaint as such because the quality of everything involved is fantastic but I wish I could have seen a little more about Yamcha during the Namek Arc or prior to the arrival of Vegeta and Nappa as the story skips around quite a lot. We do get some slight looks at Yamcha fighting Burter or Tambourine and although the outcome is predictable due to the nature of the story I wish I could have seen some of that action.

Overall I really enjoyed this Manga because it did something different while remaining linked to the core of Dragon ball, a nice fun adventure. In no way do I want to see the market flooded with titles like this and I feel like you need to have a franchise like Dragon Ball to be able to do something like this effectively. Nevertheless I would love to see some more crazy stories set in the Dragon Ball world whether they are canon or not.

I hope the Dragon Ball Room continues to expand and give new artists and writers a chance to shine, especially those with proven track records from within the community like Toyotaro and LEE. I will say that I believe they have to be particularly selective in who they allow to take the wheel of such an important franchise.

I think if you're a fan of the series and want a short but great read then you absolutely have to pick this Manga up when you can, you won't be disappointed!

Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam (1985)

 

It’s been a really long time since I posted here but I wanted to talk about a series I rewatched recently called Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam from 1985 which was the first in a series of sequels to the original Mobile Suit Gundam. I’ve been collecting the Blu Rays of the Gundam series recently as they have slowly started to come to the UK thanks to the fine folks at AlltheAnime and Zeta was one of my favourites when I first watched it almost 10 years ago.

Now I’ve seen pretty much everything Gundam related that’s been released but Zeta had always had that status for me that it was one of the highest points the franchise could hope to reach and from what I’ve seen online from the fan base this seems to be the general opinion.  I remember I really enjoyed it when I originally saw it but I feel almost 10 years is enough time to warrant a rewatch of the series and re-evaluate if I still hold it in high regard. So allow me just to pick a few things I liked as disliked about the show this time around.

I think right off the bat I need to mention how in love I am with the Mecha designs in Zeta. They are absolutely some of the best in the Universal Century and in the Gundam franchise itself. I have to say they know how to take simplistic designs and add to them such as the Gundam Mk II which is pretty much the original Gundam with only small ‘upgrades’. While this keeps the Mobile Suit looking new and perhaps sleeker it doesn’t hesitate to preserve some elements that made the original suit so iconic. 

To counter this point they are also not afraid to take what we are already familiar with and totally change it. For example the Zeta Gundam itself was different from anything we had seen up until that point. The famous Gundam head design was refined and the transformation gimmick gave a real sense of changing times for the series both in the show itself and to its fans. 

I am happy they kept with the general theme of the ‘bad guys’ having single 'mono-eyed' Mobile Suits even more so in this series because the Titans who are this shows antagonists used to be considered the ‘good guys’ in the previous series but have become their own entity not governed by the Earth Federation. By having them go back to using Mobile Suits typically associated with ‘evil’ and even having an in-show reason for this such as Zeon technology being more advanced I felt it really helped to emphasise that the Titans were to a corrupt version of the Earth Federation.

One of the best aspects of the show is Char now being a protagonist under the name of Quattro. Char was the primary rival in the original series whose motivations were never exactly clear until partway through that show. It was questionable whether he was evil or just saw things from another perspective. I find that is the case for many factions and characters within the Universal Century and feel this only boosts Chars appeal to fans.

In this show we see a new side of him where he has become a true leader and Father figure or Teacher to many of the younger cast members, specifically Kamille who I feel at times could either be the next Amuro or the next Char. I feel that Char can see this too and attempts to mould him in that direction. I would not say he is doing this for any ulterior motive I truly believe he sees it as his own way of paving the road for the next generation and Newtypes in general.

 

I find that the protagonist of the show Kamille shows real growth and development throughout the series. He is annoying at first and very childish but as the show progresses he really grows into an adult and a capable pilot. I think his progression raises interesting questions such as how a teenager would react in a literal war zone when they are the pilot of arguably the most important machine in the war. This of course is answered in the original series too but this time around Kamille is surrounded by people who have done this before and are in many cases Veterans.

Now while he does show he is a capable person over time he does have a number of missteps where he lets his emotions run wild. With examples such as when a friend is killed or when the love of his life is actually under the control of the enemy and has their memories tampered with. It takes Kamille a long time to start using his emotions as a weapon in order to benefit his faction but once he does he becomes a force to be reckoned with. 

Kamille most of the time as mentioned above shows that he could go either the way of Char or the way of  previous series protagonist Amuro. This is shown quite early on in the series when he loses Four Murasame in a situation quite close to that of what Amuro and Char went through when Lalah was killed in Mobile Suit Gundam. What is important and allows Kamille to stand out though is that he doesn’t specifically follow either characters advice and allows himself to pave his own way. By being able to do this he is not just a mirror image of his seniors he is his own person and a much more interesting character because of it. I feel this point is the main reason he matures throughout the show.

I also have to say I found Jerid likeable at times. Jerid was this aggressive rival to Kamille right off the bat purely because he thought Kamille was a girl’s name… While this starts off extremely petty each one of them continues to antagonise the other with Jerid always rushing into battle the moment he knows Kamille is on the battlefield. This has consequences for both characters though as each one of them end up killing those close to the other party.

Naturally this only intensifies their hate for one another but in a roundabout way it showed that Jerid actually was a good pilot and could continue to improve. At times it would even show he had leadership skills and those that would follow him. Personally, I feel he had the edge at times as he was continuously getting new mobile suits to pilot yet he really could have become a Newtype to rival Kamille if he had lived longer.

As much as I enjoy much of the characterisations in the show I do feel that some characters seem to have ridiculous motivations for what they do. The worst offender for this is Reccoa who was with the AEUG from the start of the show and was a valued member of the team, she was capable and another of those the younger team would look up to. The issue is she goes on reconnaissance and meets the antagonist Scirroco and immediately begins to almost love him.

Because of this she abandons the AEUG and joins the Titans, a group of people she has fought against for some time, a group she has seen commit countless atrocities. There are times early on when she joins the Titans that she is seen to disagree with their methods but eventually she becomes just as bad as they are, all because she wishes to be closer to Scirroco.

I find this utterly ridiculous and some could argue it is because Char does not return her affection early on. Regardless we have Emma who was originally on the side of the Titans but once she begins to see how they operate she joins the AEUG because she does not agree with what the Titans has become, this is a much more reasonable explanation for someone to join another faction!

I found the pacing of the series to be quite good as I never believed there to be an episode that was not warranted like I do with a lot of Anime nowadays. Everything that happened seemed to happen for a reason and if there were ever deaths they felt like they served a real purpose to the rest of the cast. 

The last two episodes are where I feel the pacing seemed ever so slightly rushed in terms of character deaths, in the space of only a few minutes you could have two or three major players bite the dust! I think you could counter this by saying this is to show you how terrible war can be and that no particular person is actually safe just because they are one of the main cast. Zeta Gundam does do this well to be fair the show ends with both sides pretty much obliterated. The Titans have pretty much all their major players killed and are disbanded, The AEUG is crippled with only one pilot being left and our protagonist is in a comatose state. I don’t know of many other series that leave the protagonists in a state such as this! It’s aspects like this that can make me see why a lot of the fan base consider this series to be depressing. 

Personally I feel it’s not that bad as it leads into an immediate sequel ZZ Gundam albeit with a new cast joining and being much more light-hearted. But I certainly agree that the ending to this series as a whole is depressing if you are to take ZZ out of the equation. I wonder if it is jarring to people who only watch these shows in English as ZZ was not dubbed yet the follow-up movie CCA was!

Now I should mention as a side note there are three compilation movies for Zeta that were released between 2005 and 2006, I have watched them and I don’t remember enjoying them as much as the series itself as they would primarily reuse old animation and just condense the story however they would randomly add newly animated scenes which at times totally changed what happened in the original version, for example certain people who died may now have lived. 

My issue with the compilations was that it was so jarring to go from 1985 animation to mid-2000’s animation, there was nothing wrong with how either worked and I really believe they should have just reanimated the entire thing as it would help flow of the scenes and their transitions. Failing that why not just do these compilations with the original animation back in the 80s…

So overall do I still feel like Zeta is still one of my favourite series in all of Gundam? I would say no, it’s still worth a watch and I don’t regret rewatching it because it allowed me to appreciate certain elements I missed previously but I feel like its status for me has changed dramatically. As I’ve said there are plenty of elements I love about this show but I find the motivations of certain characters to be utterly ridiculous, so much so that it really makes me question what the writers were thinking at the time.

I feel there is a lot of fluff in the series that otherwise could be trimmed down and the ending is severely lacking but I’d recommend it to anyone interested specifically in Universal Century Gundam series, it is a small piece of a much larger saga and it certainly has earnt its place as it has  monumental moments for the characters such as Char, Amuro and Kamille.

Zeta you’ve got a lot of flaws, but you’ve also got some of the best Mech designs in the entire franchise, you showed us how to continue the story of the original cast while bringing in the next generation along with them and ultimately you set up a lot of major elements for the rest of Universal Century, you’re worth the watch!